Thursday, September 20, 2007

Prenatal genetic testing and relatively easy access to abortion leads to all kinds of questions about sex selection and eugenics:

What is a “designer baby” but a new consumer choice? When a vague, distorted feminism is conflated with enthusiastic consumerism, when “choice” is the catchword of both, designer babies can easily emerge as the natural, if not inevitable, next step in the evolution of our liberated, capitalist society.

Rebecca Tuhus-Dubrow takes a thorough and honest look at disentangling the ideology of eugenics from the pro-choice movement, and is eventually led to this fascinating paragraph:

The first and least controversial task for pro-choice activists, then, is to make it very clear that the rights for which they have fought are fundamentally different from the right to determine the genetic makeup of offspring. Whether the latter right is legitimate or not, it is not the same as or an extension of the former. Pro-choice activists have struggled for women’s freedom to control their own lives and bodies, not to control the lives and bodies of their children.

No comments: